Our Menu
Appetizers
Big Bavarian Pretzel
$14.00
Large pretzel twist served with queso blanco.
Fried Pickle Spears
$9.00
Hand battered pickle spears served with a side of dill sauce.
Chicken Wing Dip
$16.00
A spicy chicken and hot sauce mixture with fresh tortilla chips and pita.
Italian Tomato Pie
$8.00
Focaccia bread baked with tomato sauce and traditional Italian spices and Romano cheese served with a dollop of ricotta cheese and olive oil
Stuffed Peppers
$15.00/Traditional
$16.00/Italian
Large banana peppers filled with a cream cheese, garlic and fresh herbs, topped with a garlic aioli or Italian stuffed peppers topped with an Italian sausage parm sauce and mozzarella
Spinach Artichoke Dip
$14.00
Baby spinach, artichoke hearts, garlic, cream cheese, toasted panko crumbs, and pita points.
Queso and Nachos
$6.00/Add Taco Chicken
Nacho chips piled high and topped with our house queso, diced tomatoes, and jalapenos.
Beef on Weck Eggrolls
$16.00
Sliced roast beef with sauteed onions and kimmelweck wrapped in a crispy eggroll served with a side of horsey sauce and au jus.
Pizza and Things
Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
$18.00/Medium
$22.00/Large
each additional topping $2 (mushroom, onion, peppers, etc.)
Buffalo's Best Wings
$17.00/single
Hot, medium, mild, BBQ, Sicilian, Italian, Willies BBQ sauce, or garlic parmesan
Chicken Fingers
$15.00/Five
$23.00/Ten
Served with French Fries and your choice of sauce (hot, med, mild, bbq)
Not Your Average Pizza Log
$17.00
Thinly rolled dough stuffed with garlic, ricotta cheese, pepperoni and mozzarella cheese • Modifications: Banana Pepper | Black Olive | Garlic | Garlic Crust | Green Olives | Italian Sausage | Mozzarella | Mushrooms | Onions | Pepperoni | Ricotta | Sweet Pepper | Tomato
Salads
Add Protein: Grilled Chicken - $6 | Grilled Shrimp -$9 | Cajun Grouper- $10 | Chicken fingers - $7 | Steak- $8 • Dressings: Ranch | Thousand Islands | Italian | Blue Cheese | French | Rasp Ving • All Adds: Onions | Tomatoes | Cheddar | Fried Chicken | Romano | Croutons | Feta | Olives | Pepperonchini | Oranges | Almonds | Gorgonzola | Cucumber
Pistachio Salad
$11.00
A lettuce blend topped with tomatoes, goat cheese, roasted pistachios, red onion, and craisins served with raspberry vinaigrette.
Caesar Salad
$8.00
Chopped romaine tossed with Romano cheese, croutons and an anchovy cream dressing
Buffalo's Best Chef Salad
$8.00
Romaine and spring mix topped with grape tomatoes, black olives, red onion, cucumber, cheddar cheese and chic peas • Add Protein: Grilled Chicken | Grilled Shrimp | Cajun Grouper
Cobb Salad
$12.00
Chopped hearty greens with tomatoes, bacon, cheddar cheese, gorgonzola, egg, and pimento cheese
Gourmet Burgers
Meat Temps: Rare | Med. Rare | Medium | Med. Well | Well Done • Choice of Cheese: American | Cheddar | Pepper Jack | Provolone | Swiss • Modifications: Bacon | Cheddar | Lettuce | Tomato | Onion • All Adds: Onions | Tomatoes | Cheddar | Fried Chicken | Romano | Croutons | Feta | Olives | Pepperonchini | Oranges | Almonds | Gorgonzola | Cucumber • Choose your side: Fries | Slaw | Gouda Mac
Bacon Cheddar Burger
$19.00
Classic burger piled with bacon and cheddar cheese
Whiskey Flazed Burger
$19.00
10 oz burger with suateed onions, banana peppers, and pepper jack cheese with a whiskey bbq glaze
The Classic Cheeseburger
$16.00
10 oz steak burger topped with your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion served on a Cosotanzo roll
House Specialties
Buffalo Beef Dip
$18.00
Thinly sliced roast beef dipped in au jus on a toasted hoagie roll with mozzarella cheese and served with and a side of horseradish and au jus
Cowboy Reuben
$18.00
Smoked flank steak with a banana pepper, coleslaw, pepper jack cheese and BBQ sauce on rye
Grouper Reuben
$19.00
Blackened grouper filet on grilled rye bread with Swiss Cheese, Thousand Island dressing, and coleslaw
Chicken BLT
$16.00
Grilled chicken breast on toasted white bread with bacon, cheese, lettuce, and tomato with a chipotle mayo
Open Prime Rib Sandwich
$22.00
Tender sliced prime rib on toasted Italian bread with a stuffed pepper, provolone, aioli • Meat Temps: Rare | Med. Rare | Medium | Med. Well | Well Done
Fried Bologna
$11.00
Sliced German style bologna with carmelized onions and pimento cheese spread on a toasted roll
Meatball Bomber
$15.00
Traditional meatball hoagie topped with house parm sauce and mozzarella cheese
Greek Pita
$10.00
A toasted pita pocket filled with lettuce, tomato, red onion, black olives, feta cheese, and Greek dressing. Add cucumber $2, Chicken $7, Shrimp $9
Beef on Weck
$17.00
Thinly sliced roast beef on a kimmelweck roll with a side of au jus and horseradish
Chicken Salad Sandwich
$11.00
Grilled chicken salad witha cranberries and herbs, served on a toasted croissant with iceburg lettuce
Fresh Chop Hoagie
$16.00/Chicken
$18.00/Steak
Fresh chopped chicken or steak with sauteed onions, peppers, and topped with melted cheese.
Night Plates
Gouda Mac & Cheese
$11.00
A rich creamy Gouda cheese sauce with elbows topped with cheddar cheese. Add Chicken fingers $7 | Add steak $8 | Add both $9
Sirlion Filet
$24.00
8 oz filet of sirloin on a bed of sweet potato mashed and grilled vegetables with a Jack Daniel's reduction and fried onions.
Coconut Lime Shrimp
$19.00
A creamy coconut and lime sauce with tiger shrimp over white rice and topped with fresh chopped cilantro
Lemon Chicken
$17.00
Lemon pepper chicken breast served over cilantro lime rice mixed with grilled vegetables
Spaghetti & Meatballs
$16.00
Spaghetti topped with our house parm sauce and three homemade meatballs, finished with parmesan and herb
Cajun Alfredo
$12.00
Cajun broccoli alfredo with Farfalle Pasta | Grilled Chicken $6 | Chicken Fingers $7 | Steak $8 | Shrimp $9 | Blackened Grouper $10
Kids Menu
Choose your Side: Fries | Slaw | Gouda Mac +$4.00 | Side Salad +$1.00
Kids Flatbread
$6.99
Kids Grilled Cheese
$6.99
Kids Pasta w/ Meatballs
$6.99
Kids Burger
$6.99
Kids Fingers
$6.99
Kids Mac & Cheese
$6.99
Sides
Soup
$3.00/Cup
$5.00/Bowl
Gouda Mac
$4.00
Side of rich creamy Gouda cheese sauce with elbows and cheddar cheese
Baked Potato
$3.00
Rice
$3.00
French Fries
$4.00
Desserts
Peanut Butter Bomb
$6.00
Apple Pie
$6.00
Chocolate Eclair
$4.00
Sponge Candy Cheese Cake
$6.00
Cupcake
$3.00
Banana Cream Pie
$6.00
Hot Street Sandwich
All sandwiches come on a Costanzo kaiser roll.
Roast Beef On Weck
$12.00
Slow roasted beef on a Costanzo weck roll served with horseradish.
Buffalo's Best Steak
$11.00
Thinly sliced steak with sautéed onions, banana peppers in a blue cheese hot sauce .
Memphis Pulled Pork
$10.00
House made pulled pork topped with fries, BBQ and creamy coleslaw.
Chicken Club Sandwich
$10.00
Breaded chicken breast with bacon with lettuce tomato cheddar cheese and a Chipotle mayo.
Buffalo Chicken Finger Wrap
$10.00
Fried chicken fingers with your choice of sauce in a wrap with lettuce & tomato.
Strawberry Salad
$3.00/add Chicken
$9.00
Bed of greens topped with fresh sliced strawberries, goat cheese, diced tomato, toasted almonds and breaded chicken.
Gilroy Fries
$8.00
Crispy fries topped with garlic butter, Romano cheese, and parsley
Signature Gouda Mac & Cheese
$8.00
Freshly baked mac and cheese with a blend of cheeses including smoked Gouda.
Chicken Fingers
$12.00
Fried chicken fingers served with cripsy fries and your choice of wing sauce.
Pulled Pork or Chicken Finger Mac & Cheese
$15.00
Our creamy gouda mac and cheese topped with BBQ pulled pork or chicken fingers in your choice of wing sauce.
Fries
$7.00
Grilled Chicken Wrap
$10.00
Seasoned chicken strips with lettuce, tomato, onion, bacon and honey mustard sauce.
Buffalo's Best Lunch Package
Best Buffalo Lunch Package
$18.00/Per Person
Includes coffee station, Chef or Caesar, mini beef on weck, backed ziti with marinara chicken wings.
Buffalo's Best Taco Bar
Buffalo Best Taco Bar
$18.00/Per Person
Includes soda and coffee station, house nachos with queso, soft tortilla shells chicken and beef, lettuce, cheese, salsa, sour cream and guacamole Mexican rice.
Lunch Wraps & Sandwich Buffet
Includes Chef or Caesar salad, coffee station, choice of 3 sandwiches and 3 sides $16.00 per person.
Sandwiches
Cranberry Turkey | Turkey Club | Chicken Caesar | Roast Beef with Cheddar | Chicken Salad | Chicken Arugula | Seafood Salad | Eggplant, Spinach, Hummus | Roasted Red Pepper | Chicken Caprese.
Sides
Couscous | Quinoa Salad | Cold Green Bean Salad | American Potato Salad | Vegetable Pasta Salad | Fresh Fruit Salad |Tomato Cucumber Salad | Broccoli Salad | Cole Slaw.
Add
$4.00/Per Person
Assorted Mini Desserts | Cookies & Brownies | Mini Cheesecake Bites.
Top Carving Stations
$50.00 per person.
Buffalo River Cruise Package
$3.00/Per Person
Includes Salad Bowls, coffee station
Choice of 2:
Chef Salad with Fresh Vegetables & Cheddar | Caesar Salad | Greek Salad with Feta | Black Olives | Tomato | Red Onion | Carving Table with Fresh Rolls.
Choice of 1:
Grilled Porkloin with Fresh Chutney | Virginia Baked Ham with Fruit Glaze | Roast Top Round of Beef | Roasted Turkey.
Choice of 1:
Leg of Lamb with Mint Jelly | Strip Steak | Prime Rib.
Choice of 1:
Baked Ziti with Marinara | Ziti with Alfredo Pasta with Garlic, olive oil, basil, tomato | Vegetable Primavera (Red or White Sauce).
Choice of 1:
Au Gratin Potatoes | Garlic or Cheddar Mashed Potatoes | Herb Roasted Baby Potatoes | Garlic Buttered Spuds.
Middle Carving Stations
$40.00 per person.
Grain Mill Package
$3.00/Per Person
Includes Salad Bowls, Coffee Station.
Choice of 1 Salad:
Chef Salad with Fresh Vegetables Cheddar | Caesar Salad | Greek Salad with Feta | Black Olives | Tomato | Red Onion | Carving Table with Froth Rolls.
Choice of 2:
Grilled Porkloin with Fresh Chutney | Virginia Baked Ham with Fruit Glaze | Roast Top of Beef | Roasted Turkey.
Choice of 2:
Baked Ziti with Marinara Au Gratin Potatoes | Ziti with Alfredo Garlic or Cheddar Mashed | Pasta with Garlic, olive oil, basil, tomato, herb | Roasted Baby Potatoes | Vegetable Primavera (Red or White Sauce) | Garlic Buttered Spuds.
Carving Stations Add Ons
Salad Upgrade
$3.00/Per Person
Poached Pear Salad | Buffalo Best Signature Salad | Antipasto Salad
Carbed Entrees
$12.00/Per Person
Tenderloin | Ahi Tuna | Rack of Lamb.
Chef Prepared Pasta Station
$10.00/Per Person.
Fresh Vegetables | Chicken | Sausage | Shrimp.
Buffalo Best Display
Imported Cheeses & Crackers
$5.50/Per Person
Antipasto
$9.00/Per Person
Cured Meats, Cheeses, Marinated Vegetables.
Fresh Vegetable with Dip Crudit
$3.50/Per Person
Fresh Fruit with Yogurt Dip
$4.50/Per Person
Mediterranean Display
$5.00/Per Person
With Hummus, Tapanade, Caponade, Bruscetta with Baguettes.
Buffalos Best Homemade Nachos
$5.00/Per Person
With Buffalo Wing Dip, Hot Pepper Dip, Smoked Pico De Gallo.
Smoked Salmon
$8.00/Per Person
With Capers, Chopped Eggs, Onion, Sour Cream Dill Sauce.
Hors D'ouevres
Hors D'ouevres
Antipasto Skewers $150.00 | Caprese Skewers $150.00 | Bruscetta $150.00 | Chicken Pineapple Kabobs $150.00 | Proscutto Grasini $150.00 | Stuffed Mushrooms $150.00 | Beef Kabobs $200.00 | Bacon Wrapped Scallops $250.00 | Salmon Mousse on Baguette $300.00 | Tuna Tartar $400.00
Breakfast Buffet
Breakfast Buffet
$16.00/Per Person
Coffee | Tea | Juice Station Fresh Fruit | Assorted Danish | Scrambled Eggs | Home Fries | French Toast with Maple Syrup | Bacon & Sausage | Add Omelette Station +$6.00 per person.
Make it a Brunch
Make it a Brunch
Add +$3.00 per person (each item): Chicken Ala King | Mini Bagels with Cream Cheese & Smoked Salmon | Gouda Mac & Cheese | Baked Ziti with Marinara | Chef Salad | Cookie & Brownie Platter.
Carving Station:
Served with Fresh Rolls | Roasted Turkey Baked Ham | Roast Beef Au Jus | Add +$6.00 per person (each item) 2 for $12.00 per person.
Lunch Buffet
Includes coffee | $20.00 per person.
Choice of 1 Plated Salad:
$20.00/Per Person
Garden Salad with Fresh Vegetables | Arugula Salad with Grape Tomatoes | Cucumber & Goat Cheese Crumble | Caesar Salad with Shaved Parmesan and Croutons.
Buffet Set Up:
Fresh Rolls and Butter.
Choice of 2 Entrees:
Vegetable Napoleon with Tomato | Basil | Eggplant | Fresh Mozzerella | Hummus | Chicken Parmesan | Chicken Picatta | Champagne Chicken | Chicken Marsala | Cranberry Chicken | Chicken Florentine | Balsamic Chicken | Chicken with Spinach | Feta | Roasted Red Pepper Sauce | Chicken Pizziola Zucczhini & Yellow Squash Spaghetti Topped with Eggplant Caponata | Sliced Top Round of Beef Au Jus | Beef Tips Marsala | Smoked Beef | Brisket Beef | Stirfry Portobello | Mushroom Stuffed with Roasted Red Pepper | Asparagus | Mozzerella on a Bed of Quinoa | Breaded Pork Chops | Pulled Pork | Sliced Porkloin with Apple Bourbon Glaze | Sliced Porkloin with Peach Chutney | Italian Sausage with Peppers & Onions | Vegetable Stirfry: Broccoli, Tofu, Snow Peas, Carrots over Bean Thread Noodles | Baked Zit with Marinara | Baked Ziti with Broccoli & Alfredo | Vegetable Pasta Primavera with Marmara or Alfredo sauce | Asparagus | Goat Cheese Pasta | Pasta Gorganzola | Pasta a la Norma | Manicotti | Gouda Mac & Cheese.
Choice of any 2 Sides:
Potatoes Augratin | Garlic Mashed Potatoes | Truffle Mashed Potatoes | Potatoes O'Brien | Greek Potatoes | Herb Roasted Baby Reds | Garlic Butter Spuds | Wild Rice with Vegetables | Chef's Seasonal Vegetable Medley | Broccoli | Italian Green Beans | Green Beans | Almondin | Honey Carrots | Cucumbers with Tzatziki Sauce | Roasted Califlower Augratin | Garlic Parmesan Zucchini.
Please call us at 716-374-1796 for more information or to book today! -- Minimum requirement of 20 people Sunday - Thursday | 30 people Friday - Saturday | Additional charges for anything under minimum | Prices are subject to change without notice.
Lunch Buffet
$16.95 per person plus tax and gratuity.
Coffee, Soda, Milk, Juice
$3.00
Rolls & Butter
Chef Salad
Baked Ziti Marinara
Top Round Beef
Backed Herb Chicken
Vegetable Medley
Mashed Potatoes
The Best of Buffalo's Best
$17.00 per person plus tax and gratuity.
Pizza
Wings
Mini Beef on Weck
Pasta with Red Sauce
Chef Salad
Bar Package
Bar Package
Available upon request.
Breakfast Buffet
$14.95 per person plus tax and gratuity.
Assorted Pastries
Scrambled Eggs
Bacon or Sausage
Home Fries
French Toast
Assorted Juices
Coffee, Tea & Soda
Add Omelet Station
$23.00/Per Person
Plus Tax and Gratuity.
Brunch Buffet
$17.95 per person plus tax and gratuity.
French Toast
Scrambled Eggs
Home Fries
Choice of two:
Chicken Parm | Roast Beef Pulled Pork | Chef Salad | Coffee | Tea | Soda.
Add Assorted Mini Desserts
$2.00/Per Person
Cookies & Brownies.
Dinner & Buffet
$18.95 per person plus tax and gratuity.
Choice of Two Entrees and Two Sides
Includes Salad, Dinner Rolls & Butter, Coffee and Soda.
Dinner Entrees
Chicken Parm
Pulled Pork
Italian Sausage
With peppers & onions.
Chicken Marsala
Roast Beef Au Jus
Famous Amos Chicken
Almond Crusted Chicken
Bloomin' Onion Chicken
Bruchetta Chicken
Chicken or Sausage Cacciatore
Chicken Cordon Bleu
Stuffed Shells
Eggplant Parm
Tortellini
With gorgonzola cream sauce.
Pasta Gorgonzola
Pasta Con Vodka
Pasta Alfredo
Manicotti Pasta with Sausage or Meatballs
Meat or Cheese Lasagna
Vegetable Lasagna
Ravioli with Red Sauce
Shrimp Tortellini
Add $2.00 per person.
Beef Burgundy
Add $2.00 per person.
Stuffed Pork Loin
Add $2.00 per person.
Beef Stroganoff
Add $2.00 per person.
Dinner Sides
Pasta with Red Sauce
Mashed Potatoes with Gravy
Garlic or Cheddar Mashed Potatoes
3 Cheese Mac & Cheese
Green Bean Almondine
Broccoli Wild Rice
Vegetable Medley Roasted Potatoes
Parsley Butter Boiled Potatoes
Pasta Salad
Potato Salad
Hors D'ouevres
Fresh Crutide with Dip
$2.00
Priced per person.
Bruschetta with Toast Points
$2.00
Priced per person.
Chips & Salsa
$2.00
Priced per person.
Assorted Cheese & Crackers
$2.50
Priced per person.
Fresh Fruit Platter with Yoghurt
$2.50
Priced per person.
Buffalo Wing Dip
$2.50
Priced per person.
Spinach Artichoke Dip
$2.50
Priced per person.
Fruit Cheese & Veggie Display
$5.00
Priced per person.
Tony's Antipasto Platter
$6.00
Priced per person.
Carved Beef Tenderloin with Rolls
$9.95
Priced per person.
Taco Bar
$10.25
Priced per person.
Pasta Station
$16.95
Priced per person.
Smoked Salmon Display
$70.00
Per side of fish.
Swedish Meatballs
$0.55
Priced per piece.
Fried Ravioli
$0.70
Priced per piece.
Chicken Satay
$1.50
Priced per piece.
Beef Wellington
$2.50
Priced per piece.
Stuffed Mushrooms
$1.50
Priced per piece.
Scallops in Bacon
$2.50
Priced per piece.
Sesame Shrimp
$2.50
Priced per piece.
Coconut Shrimp
$2.50
Priced per piece.
Crab Cake
$2.50
Priced per piece.
Beef Kebob
$3.00
Priced per piece.
Bacon Shrimp
$2.50
Priced per piece.
Join us every Sunday from 10 am - 1 pm for our delicious omelets. You can pick and choose your desired meats and vegetables to stuff your omelet!
Omelet Station
Select from the following ingredients for your omelet: sausage, bacon, ham, mushrooms, peppers, cheese, onions, spinach, tomatoes, and jalapenos.
Omelet Station
$10.00
Select from the following ingredients for your omelet: sausage, bacon, ham, mushrooms, peppers, cheese, onions, spinach, tomatoes, and jalapenos.